How to choose a kitchen knife: blade steel, knife types, handle fit and keeping it sharp

A good kitchen knife is the one you reach for every day. That depends less on brand than on blade shape, steel and hardness, how the handle fits your hand, and whether you will keep the edge sharp. Here is what makers and testers say about each.

The Review NYU is not affiliated with New York University.

We do not currently earn a commission from any link on this page. If links ever become affiliate links, we will label them clearly.

Short answer. Start with one chef's knife (or a gyuto or santoku) that feels balanced in a pinch grip; add a paring and bread knife only if you need them. Softer German-style steel, which WÜSTHOF hardens to 58 HRC, is more forgiving; harder Japanese steels, which Shun hardens to 60 to 62 HRC, hold a thinner edge longer but chip more easily. Hone regularly, sharpen only when honing stops working, and keep it out of the dishwasher.

How we judged

The Review NYU did not test any knives. This guide is research-based: we read manufacturer pages from WÜSTHOF, Shun (Kai USA) and Böker, guidance from the specialist retailers Knifewear and Chef Knives To Go, and America's Test Kitchen's overview of sharpening methods, all checked on 19 November 2026. Hardness and edge angles depend on each maker's heat treatment and grinding, so we name the brand behind every figure. Claims like "super steel" are reported as claims, not measurements.

Kitchen knife types and what each one is for

Knifewear says most people only need a chef's knife (gyuto), a vegetable knife (nakiri) and a utility knife (petty), and if you want just one, it should be the gyuto.

TypeBest forWho needs it
Chef's knife / gyutoChopping, slicing, mincing almost anything. Knifewear says 210 mm and 240 mm are the most common gyuto lengths.Everyone. Buy it first.
SantokuShorter all-rounder, flat near the heel for vegetables, curving to the tip.Cooks who prefer a shorter blade.
Paring / pettyPeeling in the hand, trimming, coring.Almost everyone, as a second knife.
Bread / serratedCrusty bread and tomatoes, where a straight edge slides.Anyone who buys whole loaves.
UtilityMid-size blade for sandwiches and small jobs.Optional; overlaps with a petty.
NakiriFlat edge for push-chopping vegetables cleanly.Vegetable-heavy cooks.
BoningNarrow blade for separating meat from bone.People who break down whole chickens or roasts.

Shun says its hard, thin knives should not be used on bones, joints or frozen foods. Knifewear's rule: if it would hurt to bite it, don't cut it.

Blade steel: German vs Japanese, stainless vs carbon

Harder steel holds an edge longer and can be ground thinner, but it is more brittle. Softer steel dulls sooner but bends rather than chips and is easier to sharpen. Hardness is quoted on the Rockwell C scale (HRC); Shun says each extra point is roughly 10% harder, its own figure.

SteelHardness (maker figures)StrengthsTrade-offs
German-style stainless (e.g. X50CrMoV15)55 to 56 HRC (Böker); 58 HRC forged, 55 to 57 non-forged (WÜSTHOF)Tough, forgiving, easy to sharpenDulls sooner; needs frequent honing
Japanese stainless (VG10, VG-MAX)60 to 61 HRC (Shun)Thinner, more acute edge that lastsCan micro-chip with hard chopping
Powder steel (SG2)61 to 62 HRC (Shun)Long edge life at high hardnessCosts more; harder to sharpen
Carbon steelVaries by makerTakes a very keen edgeRusts quickly; dry it immediately

Böker lists X50CrMoV15 as 0.45 to 0.55% carbon and 14 to 15% chromium, with small amounts of molybdenum and vanadium. Its 55 to 56 HRC differs from WÜSTHOF's 58 HRC for forged blades, which shows why you should read the hardness on the product page rather than infer it from a steel name. Knifewear says Japanese knives start around 58 to 60 HRC and go to 65 to 66 and beyond; the hardest are easy to chip. Shun calls SG2 powder steel less brittle at high hardness, a vendor claim we did not verify. Our guide to reading a spec sheet helps with vague listings.

Edge angle

Shun says German knives use thicker blades sharpened to 20 to 25 degrees per side, while it sharpens its own to 16. Chef Knives To Go gives 15 to 17 degrees for Japanese knives and 20 to 25 for Western ones. WÜSTHOF's instructions use 14.5 degrees for its knives and 10 for Asian-style ones. Use your maker's figure.

Rust

Knifewear sorts steel into stainless (low maintenance), semi-stainless or stainless-clad carbon (wash and dry promptly) and carbon (wipe it every time you set it down). Stainless is not rust-proof: Shun says moisture left on the blade can still cause rust.

Forged vs stamped blades

A forged blade is shaped from heated steel; a stamped or laser-cut blade is cut from a sheet. WÜSTHOF says its forged knives take more than 54 manufacturing steps versus 35 for laser-cut ones, and usually have a bolster that adds weight and moves the balance toward your hand. Forged is not automatically better: WÜSTHOF calls its non-forged knives lighter, more maneuverable and "just as sharp." Choose by weight and balance.

Handle, balance and fit

Shun's advice is simple: hold a knife before you buy it. Test it in the pinch grip WÜSTHOF describes: thumb on the flat of the blade near the bolster, index finger curled on the other side, other fingers around the handle, wrist relaxed and straight. Then check:

  • Balance: neither tip-heavy nor pulling back toward the handle.
  • Knuckle clearance: your knuckles clear the board at the bottom of a chop.
  • Size: fingers close without cramping or a large gap. Smaller hands may prefer a shorter gyuto or santoku.
  • Shape: Shun's D-shaped Classic handle is designed for right-handers, though the company says many left-handers like it.
  • Corners: sharp edges on the spine or handle become sore spots.

Synthetic handles shrug off water. Wood needs care; WÜSTHOF suggests a few drops of food-grade mineral oil on wooden handles.

How to keep a kitchen knife sharp

America's Test Kitchen notes that a sharp knife needs less force and is less likely to slide off food, so it is safer than a dull one.

Honing vs sharpening

Honing straightens a rolled edge; sharpening grinds away steel to make a new one. Shun says a honing steel realigns the edge without removing metal, while ceramic and diamond rods sharpen. WÜSTHOF recommends 6 to 8 alternating strokes from heel to tip at its angle. Sharpen when honing no longer helps, for example when the knife will not glide through tomato skin; Shun warns against sharpening weekly because it removes steel.

Sharpening options

  • Whetstone: most control, but ATK says there is a learning curve; practice on a cheap knife.
  • Electric: ATK's top pick restored dull knives in about two minutes but is bulky. Match the angle to your knife.
  • Pull-through: compact, fine for dull but undamaged blades, per ATK. WÜSTHOF says to pull heel to tip with only the knife's weight. Chef Knives To Go, which sells stones, says pull-throughs leave a coarser edge.
  • Professional: ATK says a good pro usually beats a home edge.

For stones, Chef Knives To Go recommends a 1000-grit stone plus a 3000 or 4000-grit finisher for most cooks, with 200 to 400 grit only for chips or very dull edges.

Boards, washing and storage

Kitchen knife buying checklist

  1. Pick the shape first: chef's knife or gyuto, or a santoku if you prefer shorter.
  2. Choose stainless unless you will dry the knife every time.
  3. Softer steel (about 55 to 58 HRC) if you chop hard; harder (60 HRC and up) if you slice gently.
  4. Note the maker's edge angle so you can hone and sharpen to match.
  5. Hold it in a pinch grip and check balance and knuckle clearance.
  6. Check the return policy; see testing during the return window.
  7. Budget for a honing rod and a sharpening method.

Should you buy a knife set or single knives?

Usually single knives. A block set spreads your budget across blades you will rarely use. Knifewear says to start with a knife you will use daily, and even WÜSTHOF, which sells sets, says there is no universal, perfect knife. Buy a chef's knife and honing rod, then add paring and bread knives as needed. A set makes sense for an empty kitchen or a gift. If one is discounted, check whether the sale is real; the same "buy what you will use" rule applies to a stand mixer.

Bottom line

Buy one well-fitting chef's knife first. Pick softer German-style stainless for a tough, low-fuss blade, or harder Japanese stainless for a thinner edge that lasts longer if you slice rather than chop. Skip carbon steel unless you enjoy the upkeep. Hone at the maker's angle, sharpen only when honing stops working, and hand-wash. A modest knife kept sharp beats an expensive dull one.

Limits of this article

  • Research-based: we did not handle or test any knife, sharpener or whetstone.
  • Hardness, angle and steel figures come from makers and retailers that sell these products; we did not verify them independently, and they apply only to the brands named.
  • We left out AUS-8 and Victorinox, Global and Henckels specifications because we could not confirm current maker figures.
  • No prices or product photos: prices change often and we have no licensed images.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

What kitchen knife should I buy first?

A chef's knife or its Japanese equivalent, the gyuto. It handles most chopping, slicing and mincing.

Are Japanese knives better than German knives?

Neither is better overall. Japanese knives are usually harder and thinner, so they stay sharp longer but can chip. German-style knives are softer and tougher, and more forgiving of hard chopping.

What is the difference between honing and sharpening?

Honing realigns a rolled edge without removing metal. Sharpening grinds away steel to make a new edge. Hone often and sharpen only when honing stops helping.

Can kitchen knives go in the dishwasher?

WÜSTHOF and Shun both say no, citing heat, knives knocking together and harsh detergents. Hand-wash and dry immediately.

What whetstone grit should a beginner buy?

Chef Knives To Go recommends a 1000-grit stone plus a 3000 or 4000-grit finishing stone.

Should I buy a knife block set?

Usually not. One good chef's knife and a honing rod, with paring and bread knives added later, is better value for most cooks.