How to choose a mechanical keyboard for typing or gaming: switches, layouts, keycaps and connections

The right mechanical keyboard depends on three choices: the switch under each key, how many keys you keep, and how it connects. This guide explains each one using makers' specs and independent test notes, so you can buy for how you actually type and play.

The Review NYU is not affiliated with New York University.

We do not currently earn a commission from any link on this page. If links ever become affiliate links, we will label them clearly.

Short answer. Pick the switch first: light linear switches (Cherry lists its MX2A Red at 45 cN and 2.0 mm pre-travel) for gaming, tactile for typing, clicky only if noise is fine, or a magnetic Hall-effect board for adjustable actuation in competitive games. Then choose a size that keeps only the keys you use (a TKL has around 87 keys), PBT or double-shot keycaps, and a wired or 2.4 GHz connection for games, since RTINGS says Bluetooth usually has the highest latency. Prefer a hot-swappable board so you can change switches later.

How we judged

This is a research-based guide. The Review NYU did not put any keyboards or switches on a desk for this article. Instead, we read switch makers' own specification pages, keyboard makers' technical spec sheets and the published explainers and test methods of RTINGS, a lab that measures keyboard latency with a high-speed camera. We checked every page on 21 November 2026.

Two kinds of numbers appear below, and they are not equally strong. Switch forces, travel distances, polling rates and adjustable actuation ranges are maker claims: they come from Cherry, Razer and Logitech describing their own parts. Latency comparisons between wired, 2.4 GHz and Bluetooth connections come from third-party measurement by RTINGS. We say which is which each time.

We did not rank products or quote prices. Keyboards change fast, but the decisions in this guide (switch feel, size, keycap material, connection) stay the same from one model year to the next.

Start with how you will use it

Most bad keyboard purchases come from buying for someone else's use case. A keyboard that a competitive shooter player loves can feel tiring for a novelist, and a quiet office board can feel vague in a fast game. Before reading spec sheets, answer three questions:

  • What is the split between typing and gaming? Long writing sessions reward a switch with clear feedback and keycaps that feel good after hours. Fast games reward light, short-travel switches and low latency.
  • Where will it live? A shared office, a dorm room or a late-night desk next to a sleeping partner rules out loud clicky switches.
  • Which keys do you actually press? If you enter numbers all day you need a numpad. If you never touch it, removing it frees space for your mouse.

Keep those answers in mind; every section below maps back to them.

Switch types: linear, tactile and clicky

The switch under each key decides most of how a keyboard feels and sounds. Mechanical switches fall into three families.

Linear

A linear switch moves straight down with no bump. Cherry lists its MX2A Red at 45 cN actuation force, 2.0 mm pre-travel and 4.0 mm total travel, and describes it as linear with no click. Cherry's own explainer says the Red is popular with players of fast games because it triggers with little force. The MX Black is also linear but, per Cherry's switch overview, needs about 60 cN, which Cherry says helps avoid accidental presses. Speed variants shorten the distance: Cherry gives its MX Silver Speed a 1.2 mm pre-travel at 45 cN.

Tactile

A tactile switch has a small bump you feel at the actuation point, but no click. Cherry's overview lists the MX Brown at 55 cN with 2 mm of pre-travel and says it is usually preferred by office users and by gamers who also type a lot. The bump tells your finger the key has registered, which helps some typists stop pressing all the way to the bottom.

Clicky

A clicky switch adds an audible click to the bump. Cherry's MX Blue needs 60 cN and actuates at 2.2 mm, according to the same Cherry overview, which also notes that the noise makes it a poor fit for open-plan offices. Clicky switches are the most polarizing choice: many typists like the feedback, and many housemates and coworkers do not.

Silent versions

Several makers sell dampened versions of linear and tactile switches. Cherry says its MX Silent switches add a two-component stem that reduces the noise of the key hitting the bottom and top without changing the switching characteristics.

Switch (maker spec)TypeActuation forcePre-travelGood fit
Cherry MX2A RedLinear45 cN2.0 mmGaming, light-touch typing
Cherry MX BlackLinearabout 60 cN2 mmTypists who rest heavy fingers on keys
Cherry MX Silver SpeedLinear45 cN1.2 mmFast games
Cherry MX BrownTactile55 cN2 mmMixed typing and gaming, offices
Cherry MX BlueClicky60 cN2.2 mmSolo typists who want audible feedback

Source: maker figures from Cherry's MX2A Red product page and Cherry's MX switch overview, checked 21 November 2026. Other brands' switches with the same color names can use different forces.

A practical note: switch colors are a convention, not a standard. A "red" from another brand may be lighter or heavier than Cherry's. Always read the force and travel numbers on the specific switch, not just the color.

Magnetic Hall-effect and analog switches

A newer category replaces the metal contact inside the switch with a magnet and a sensor. RTINGS explains that Hall-effect switches have small magnets in the stem and a sensor on the circuit board under each key that tracks the magnetic field as the key moves. Because the keyboard knows how far each key is pressed, it can do things a contact switch cannot:

  • Adjustable actuation. Razer, for example, claims its HE magnetic switches have an adjustable actuation range of 0.1 to 4.0 mm, set in its software. You can make keys trigger almost at the touch for gaming, or deeper to avoid typos.
  • Rapid Trigger. The key resets as soon as it starts to rise, instead of at a fixed point, so repeated taps and quick strafing in shooters can register faster. This is a maker-described feature; how much it helps depends on the game and the player.
  • Analog input. Some boards can report partial presses, similar to a controller trigger, in games that support it.

The trade-offs are compatibility and complexity. RTINGS notes that magnetic keyboards have no single standard: magnets can face different directions and differ in strength, and circuit boards are calibrated for specific switches, so swapping in another brand's magnetic switches may not work reliably. If you mostly type, a magnetic board adds settings you may never use. If you play competitive shooters or rhythm games, it is the category most worth considering.

Hot-swap: why it is worth paying for

A hot-swappable keyboard lets you pull switches out and push new ones in without soldering. RTINGS describes how hot-swap sockets work: the maker solders small spring-loaded sockets to the circuit board, and the switch pins slot into them. For a first-time buyer this is the cheapest insurance against choosing the wrong switch, because you can change the feel later instead of buying a new keyboard.

Things to check:

  • 3-pin or 5-pin. Most hot-swap boards accept Cherry MX-style switches. RTINGS explains that 5-pin switches add two plastic stabilizing pins; they fit a 3-pin board only if you clip those pins off, while 3-pin switches fit 5-pin sockets but may feel less stable.
  • Low-profile boards. RTINGS warns that Cherry MX Low-Profile, Gateron Low-Profile and Kailh Choc switches use different standards and are not interchangeable.
  • Durability. According to RTINGS, some early sockets were rated for about 100 insertions, while newer sockets from Kailh and Gateron are rated for tens of thousands of cycles. Sockets can still collect debris and cause chatter (double keystrokes).

If you know exactly which switch you want and never plan to change it, a soldered board is fine and often cheaper. Everyone else should treat hot-swap as a near-requirement.

Layouts and sizes: full, TKL, 75%, 65%, 60% and split

Size is about which key groups a keyboard keeps, not its exact dimensions. RTINGS stresses that keyboard sizes are guidelines, not strict standards, so two boards with the same label can have different key counts.

SizeTypical keysWhat you loseBest for
Full-size (100%)104 to 108Nothing; widest footprintNumber entry, spreadsheets, people who use every key
96% (compact full)Close to full-sizeGaps between key groups; some rarely used keysNumpad users short on desk space
TKL (80%)Around 87NumpadMost gamers and typists; mouse sits closer to center
75%VariesNumpad; navigation keys are squeezed inSmall footprint while keeping function row and arrows
65%Varies by makerNumpad and function row; keeps arrowsCompact typing with arrow keys
60%Around 61Function row, arrows, navigation cluster, numpad (reached via Fn layers)Competitive FPS players who want maximum mouse space

Source: key counts and trade-offs from RTINGS' keyboard size guide, checked 21 November 2026. RTINGS does not give a fixed count for 75% or 65% boards because they vary by maker.

RTINGS makes two points worth repeating. First, removing the numpad lets you keep your mouse closer to your body, which can reduce strain in long sessions. Second, 60% boards rely on layers: arrows and function keys live behind an Fn key. That can be efficient once learned, but it is a real adjustment if you edit text or code with arrow keys all day.

Split and ergonomic keyboards

Split keyboards separate the two halves so each hand sits at shoulder width, and some add tenting (raising the middle) or column-staggered keys. They have a learning curve and usually need a uniform-height keycap set if you want to customize them; Wooting's knowledge base notes that uniform profiles such as XDA suit ergonomic and split keyboards. If wrist or shoulder discomfort is why you are shopping, think about the whole desk, including your chair height; our guide on how to choose an ergonomic office chair covers that side.

Also check the language layout (ANSI or ISO). RTINGS notes that layout, such as the shape of the Enter key, is separate from size, and it matters if you buy replacement keycaps.

Keycaps: profiles and ABS vs PBT

Profiles

Keycap profile is the shape and height of the caps. Wooting's keycap profile explainer summarizes the common ones:

  • OEM: the most common profile on prebuilt keyboards, slightly curved and sculpted by row.
  • Cherry: sculpted like OEM but lower overall, a popular choice in the enthusiast community.
  • SA and MT3: tall, sculpted, retro-looking profiles; some people love the feel, others find them too high.
  • DSA and XDA: uniform profiles where every row is the same shape, which makes caps easy to rearrange.

Sculpted profiles (OEM, Cherry) help touch typists find rows by feel. Uniform profiles look clean and suit unusual layouts. Taller profiles generally need a wrist rest for comfort.

Materials

Most keyboards ship with ABS or PBT caps. RTINGS' ABS vs PBT explainer sets out the differences:

ABSPBT
FeelSmooth at first, becomes glossy and slippery with useMatte, slightly textured, keeps its feel longer
ShineMost people see shine after about two years, per RTINGSLittle visible change for several years
SoundBrighter, higher pitchDeeper, more muted
BacklightingPasses light better; brighter legendsLegends often look dimmer
CostUsually cheaper, more color choicesUsually more expensive

Source: RTINGS, ABS vs PBT Keycaps, checked 21 November 2026. Wear rates vary with skin chemistry, according to RTINGS.

Legend method matters as much as material. RTINGS explains that double-shot caps mold the legend in a second plastic, so it cannot wear off, while dye-sublimation heats ink into PBT and works best on lighter colors. Thick ABS can also be good: RTINGS notes that high-end maker GMK uses thick double-shot ABS. For a keyboard you plan to keep, PBT or thick double-shot caps are the safer default; if bright RGB legends matter most, double-shot ABS shows lighting better.

Wired vs 2.4 GHz vs Bluetooth

Connection type affects latency, battery hassle and how many devices you can switch between.

ConnectionLatency (RTINGS)Polling (example)Best for
Wired USBLowest, traditionallyMost gaming boards 1000 HzCompetitive gaming, a fixed desk
2.4 GHz receiverUsually close to wired1000 Hz (Logitech G613 claim)Gaming without a cable
BluetoothUsually highest125 Hz (Logitech G613 claim)Typing, multiple devices, travel

Source: latency comparisons from RTINGS' keyboard latency test notes; polling figures from Logitech's G613 technical specifications (maker claims), both checked 21 November 2026.

On polling rate: RTINGS explains that 1000 Hz means the keyboard reports once per millisecond, and some boards offer 2000, 4000 or even 8000 Hz. It also says the jump to 8000 Hz shaves only fractions of a millisecond. Treat very high polling numbers as a minor tie-breaker, not a reason to pay much more. RTINGS adds that you will likely not notice Bluetooth delay while typing, but you probably will in games.

A good compromise for many buyers is a tri-mode keyboard (wired, 2.4 GHz and Bluetooth): use the receiver or cable for games and Bluetooth for a tablet or work laptop.

Typing vs gaming: putting it together

Mostly typing

  • Tactile switches (Brown-style) for feedback without noise, or clicky if you work alone and like the sound.
  • Full-size, 96% or TKL if you rely on navigation keys; 75% if you want a smaller board but still use arrows and the function row.
  • PBT or thick double-shot keycaps in a sculpted profile.
  • Bluetooth or tri-mode if you switch between computers.

Mostly gaming

  • Light linear switches (Red or Speed style), or a magnetic Hall-effect board if you play competitive shooters and want adjustable actuation and Rapid Trigger.
  • TKL, 75% or 60% to leave room for wide mouse movements. Pair it with the right mouse: see our roundup of the best gaming mice.
  • Wired or 2.4 GHz, not Bluetooth, for play.
  • Hot-swap, so you can tune feel later.

Both

A hot-swappable TKL or 75% board with linear or light tactile switches and a tri-mode connection covers most people. If you are unsure about switches, some makers sell switch tester kits; Cherry, for example, offers an MX Experience Box with a range of its switches.

Buying checklist

  1. Use: estimate your typing-to-gaming split and where the keyboard will sit (shared room or not).
  2. Switch family: linear for speed, tactile for feedback, clicky only if noise is fine; consider magnetic for competitive gaming.
  3. Switch numbers: read actuation force (cN or gf) and pre-travel on the maker's page, not just the color.
  4. Hot-swap: confirm it, and whether sockets are 3-pin or 5-pin. For magnetic boards, check which switches the maker supports.
  5. Size: keep only the key groups you use; check the 75%/65% arrangement on photos because it varies.
  6. Layout: ANSI or ISO, and Mac or Windows legends if that matters to you.
  7. Keycaps: PBT or double-shot; a profile you can type on comfortably.
  8. Connection: wired or 2.4 GHz for games, Bluetooth for multi-device typing; tri-mode covers both.
  9. Software: check that remapping and lighting software runs on your operating system, or that the board supports on-board settings.
  10. Return policy: keyboard feel is personal. Buy where you can return it, and use the window well; our guide on testing a product during the return window explains how.

Bottom line

Choose the switch first, then the size, then the connection. Light linear switches suit fast games; tactile switches suit long typing sessions; clicky switches suit people who work alone. Magnetic Hall-effect boards are the strongest option for competitive gaming, with the caveat that switch compatibility is brand-specific. A hot-swappable TKL or 75% board with PBT keycaps and a 2.4 GHz plus Bluetooth connection is a sensible default for most buyers. Treat maker numbers for polling rate and actuation range as claims, and rely on independent latency testing, such as RTINGS', when speed matters.

Limits of this article

  • This guide is research based. The Review NYU did not test any keyboards or switches hands-on.
  • Switch forces, travel, actuation ranges and polling rates are maker claims from Cherry, Razer and Logitech; we did not measure them. Cherry's figures for the MX Brown, Blue, Black and Silver Speed come from a Cherry overview article first published in 2017, while the MX2A Red figures come from its current product page.
  • Latency comparisons come from RTINGS' test notes; the page we cite is an archived version of its methodology (Keyboard Latency 1.2), and results for individual keyboards vary.
  • Key counts for 75% and 65% keyboards vary by maker, so we give no fixed number. We found no single authoritative source for split and ergonomic keyboard specifications and describe them only in general terms.
  • A Keychron layout guide we tried to use returned a 404 error on 21 November 2026 and was not used.
  • No product picks or prices are included, and there are no images because we have no licensed photos.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

Which mechanical keyboard switch is best for typing?

Many typists prefer tactile switches, which have a bump at the actuation point without a click. Cherry lists its MX Brown at 55 cN with 2 mm of pre-travel and says office users usually prefer it. Clicky switches also suit typing if noise is not a problem.

Which switch is best for gaming?

Light linear switches such as Cherry's MX Red (45 cN, 2.0 mm pre-travel per Cherry) are a common choice. Magnetic Hall-effect boards go further with adjustable actuation, which Razer claims can be set from 0.1 to 4.0 mm, and Rapid Trigger.

Is a wireless mechanical keyboard good enough for gaming?

Over a 2.4 GHz USB receiver, usually yes: RTINGS says receiver latency is now usually about as low as wired. Bluetooth is different; RTINGS says it usually has the highest latency and often only a 125 Hz polling rate.

What is the difference between TKL, 75% and 60% keyboards?

A TKL drops the numpad and has around 87 keys. A 75% keeps the function row and arrows but packs them tighter. A 60% has around 61 keys and moves arrows, function keys and navigation to Fn layers, according to RTINGS.

Are PBT keycaps better than ABS?

PBT resists shine and keeps a matte texture longer, while ABS usually costs less, shows backlighting better and tends to develop shine after about two years, according to RTINGS. Thick double-shot ABS can also last well.

Do I need a hot-swappable keyboard?

It is strongly recommended for a first mechanical keyboard, because you can change switches without soldering if you dislike the feel. Check whether the sockets take 3-pin or 5-pin switches, and note that magnetic and low-profile switches are often brand-specific.