The offer usually arrives at the checkout, when you have already decided to buy and the add-on looks small next to the price. Most of the time it is not worth it. Sometimes it clearly is. The difference comes down to what you are already covered for, what a repair would cost, and what the contract actually says.
The Review NYU is not affiliated with New York University.
We do not currently earn a commission from any link on this page. If links ever become affiliate links, we will label them clearly.
Short answer. Usually not, but there are clear exceptions. An extended warranty, legally a service contract, is worth considering when a single repair would be expensive relative to the product's price, when the plan covers accidental damage you are likely to cause, and when the provider is reputable and the fine print has no large deductible or exclusions. It is rarely worth it for cheap or reliable products, or when it overlaps with cover you already have: the manufacturer's warranty, implied warranties under US state law, the EU's minimum two-year legal guarantee, or protection from your credit card. The FTC suggests a simple alternative for many buyers: put the money you would spend on the plan into savings and use it if something breaks.
This is a general buying guide, not a review of any specific plan. It is based on the FTC's consumer guidance on warranties and service contracts, the EU's official guidance on legal guarantees, and published repair prices for one current product, all checked on 10 November 2026. Where we use numbers to illustrate a calculation, we label them as hypothetical. Coverage rules differ by country, state, retailer and plan, so treat this as a way to think, not as a ruling on any particular contract.
The FTC distinguishes two things that are easy to confuse:
The seller of the service contract is not necessarily the manufacturer. It can be the retailer or a third-party company you have never heard of, and that matters when you need to make a claim.
Before paying for extra cover, check what you already have. Overlap is the most common reason an extended warranty is poor value; the FTC says a plan is "not a good value if it doesn't offer more coverage than the warranty that came with the product."
| Type of cover | What it is | Where it applies |
|---|---|---|
| Manufacturer's warranty | The written warranty included with the product; its length varies by maker and product | Everywhere; terms set by the maker |
| Implied warranties | "Unspoken promises" created by state law; the warranty of merchantability means a product will do what it is supposed to do | United States (every state, per the FTC) |
| EU legal guarantee | A minimum two-year guarantee; the seller must repair or replace faulty goods at no cost | European Union |
| Card benefits | Some credit cards add extra warranty time on purchases made with the card | Depends on your card; check its benefits guide |
| Home or renters insurance | May cover theft or some damage, usually not wear or breakdowns | Depends on your policy |
One more US protection is worth knowing: the FTC says federal law prevents a manufacturer from requiring you to use specific parts or services to keep your warranty, unless it provides them free or has an FTC waiver. Independent repair alone does not automatically void your cover.
A plan is most likely to be worth it when several of these are true at once:
You do not need exact failure rates to make a sensible decision. Compare the plan's cost with the repair it would cover and how likely you think that repair is.
Hypothetical example: a plan costs $150 for three years and covers a repair that would cost $600, with a $50 deductible per claim. The plan saves you $550 if that repair happens once. For the plan to break even, you would need to believe there is better than about a 27 percent chance of needing that repair during the term ($150 divided by $550). If you think the chance is much lower, the plan is likely to cost you more than it saves. If you think it is higher, or a repair bill would cause real hardship, the plan looks better.
Two adjustments make the estimate more honest. First, subtract the months the free warranty already covers, because the plan only adds value after that. Second, add every fee: the FTC lists deductibles, per-service fees, shipping to a repair centre and transfer fees as hidden costs to look for.
The FTC's checklist covers five areas. Here they are as questions to answer before you pay:
Get the full contract, not the brochure, before you pay. If the seller cannot show it to you, that is your answer.
| Situation | Usually |
|---|---|
| Cheap item you could replace easily | Skip it |
| Plan overlaps the manufacturer's warranty or your card's cover | Skip it, or buy later if the plan allows |
| Expensive, fragile device you carry every day, with accidental damage covered | Consider it |
| A single repair would cost a large share of the price, and you could not absorb it | Consider it |
| Unknown third-party provider, unclear claims process or large deductibles | Skip it |
| Offer arrives by phone or mail long after you bought | Do not engage; report it to the FTC |
Some plans can be bought for a period after purchase rather than only at the till. If so, you can take the product home, read the contract calmly and decide later.
Usually not for cheap or reliable products, or when it overlaps cover you already have. It can be worth it for expensive, fragile products when a single repair would cost a large share of the price, especially if the plan covers accidental damage and comes from a reputable provider with low deductibles.
A warranty comes with the product at no extra cost. An extended warranty, also called a service contract, costs extra, is sold separately and may cover different problems than the manufacturer's warranty, according to the FTC.
Check the upfront price and any deductibles or per-repair fees, shipping costs, payout caps, exactly what is covered and excluded, whether accidental damage is included, when cover starts, who backs the plan and how claims work. The FTC advises assuming anything not listed in the contract is not covered.
Often yes. Most products include a manufacturer's warranty, US state law creates implied warranties on almost everything you buy, the EU requires a minimum two-year legal guarantee, and some credit cards extend warranties on purchases made with the card.
Not automatically in the US. The FTC says federal law prevents a manufacturer from requiring specific parts or services to keep the warranty, unless it provides them free or has an FTC waiver.
Be very cautious. The FTC warns that calls and mail selling extended warranties often come from marketers unrelated to the company you bought from, use high-pressure tactics, and that such robocalls are probably illegal if you have no connection with the caller.