The best AI coding tools compared: tools, with what each one does, what it costs and who it suits.
Software development has been transformed faster by AI than almost any other kind of work. Code completion that suggests whole functions, chat assistants that explain error messages, editors that rewrite files on request and agents that plan, code, run tests and open pull requests have all arrived within a few years. For students learning to program, AI can be a patient tutor. For professionals, it can remove a lot of tedious work.
It can also produce subtly wrong code, introduce security problems, slow experienced developers down and leave learners unable to code without it. This section looks at AI coding tools with a clear eye: what kinds exist, what the evidence says about productivity, where they help and hurt, and how to use them safely. Our guide to AI coding tools compares tool types in more detail. Descriptions of products are based on companies' own materials, and the field changes month to month.
Stack Overflow's 2025 Developer Survey found that 84 percent of respondents were using or planning to use AI tools in their development process, up from 76 percent the year before, and that 51 percent of professional developers used AI tools daily. The same survey found more developers distrusted the accuracy of AI tools, 46 percent, than trusted it, 33 percent, with only 3 percent reporting high trust. Heavy use combined with low trust is a fair summary of where the profession stands.
The research is genuinely mixed, and the differences tell you a lot about when AI helps.
| Study | Setting | Finding |
|---|---|---|
| Peng and colleagues, 2023 | Recruited developers writing an HTTP server in JavaScript | Developers with GitHub Copilot completed the task 55.8% faster |
| METR, 2025 | 16 experienced open source developers, 246 real tasks on their own large repositories | Developers took 19% longer when AI tools were allowed, despite expecting to be faster |
The first study involved a well defined, self contained task, the kind AI tools handle well. The second involved experienced developers working on mature, complex codebases they knew intimately, where understanding context, conventions and subtle requirements matters more than typing speed. In the METR study, developers had forecast that AI would make them 24 percent faster and, even after the experiment, believed it had sped them up. That gap between perception and measurement is a strong reason to measure your own results.
| Task | Why AI helps |
|---|---|
| Boilerplate and repetitive code | Patterns are common and easy to verify |
| Unfamiliar languages and libraries | Suggests idiomatic usage and explains APIs |
| Writing tests | Generates cases quickly for code you understand |
| Explaining code and errors | Translates stack traces and legacy code into plain language |
| Small scripts and prototypes | Low stakes, quick to check |
| Documentation and comments | Drafts that you edit for accuracy |
| Learning concepts | Patient explanations and examples |
| Situation | Why |
|---|---|
| Large, mature codebases | Missing context about architecture and conventions |
| Subtle business logic | Requirements that live in people's heads, not code |
| Security sensitive code | Plausible but insecure patterns |
| New or niche libraries | Outdated or invented APIs |
| Performance critical code | Correct looking but inefficient solutions |
| Long autonomous tasks | Errors compound across steps |
AI generated code can include vulnerabilities, outdated dependencies, invented packages and licensing questions. Treat AI suggestions like code from an unknown contributor: review it, test it and run your normal security checks. Be especially careful with authentication, encryption, input handling and anything that touches user data or payments. Never paste secrets such as API keys or passwords into AI tools, and check your employer's rules about sending proprietary code to external services. The U.S. National Institute of Standards and Technology's AI Risk Management Framework encourages organisations to manage risks such as security and reliability when adopting AI; in practice, that means keeping code review, testing and security scanning in place regardless of who or what wrote the code.
For students, AI is a double edged tool. It can explain concepts, give hints, review code and generate practice problems. It can also do assignments for you, which skips the struggle that builds real skill and may break course rules. A useful approach is to attempt problems yourself first, ask AI for hints rather than full solutions, ask it to explain any code it suggests line by line and regularly code without it to check you can. Follow your course's policy on AI, and be honest about how you used it.
Because perception and reality can differ, it is worth measuring. A simple approach is to keep a short log for two weeks. For each task, note whether you used AI, roughly how long the task took, how much time went into reviewing and fixing AI output and whether bugs appeared later. Compare similar tasks with and without AI. Teams can look at cycle time, review time, defect rates and incidents before and after adopting tools. The goal is not to prove AI good or bad, but to learn where it helps your particular work and where it gets in the way.
Code review becomes more important, not less, when AI writes code. AI can produce large amounts of plausible code quickly, which can overwhelm reviewers and hide subtle problems. Good practices include keeping changes small, asking authors to explain AI generated changes in their own words, requiring tests for new code and using automated linters and security scanners. Some teams ask contributors to note when significant portions were AI generated, so reviewers know where to look more closely.
For teams, the choice of AI coding tools involves more than individual preference. Consider data handling and where code is sent, administrative controls and audit logs, integration with existing editors and repositories, licensing and intellectual property terms, cost per seat and support. Pilot tools with a small group on real work, gather measurements and feedback, and write clear guidelines on acceptable use before rolling them out widely.
Coding agents can now read a repository, plan changes across many files, run commands and tests, and propose pull requests. Used carefully, they can handle well scoped tasks such as updating dependencies, fixing straightforward bugs or adding tests. They also amplify risk: an agent can make many changes quickly, run commands with side effects and introduce errors that are hard to spot in a large diff. Start agents on low risk tasks, run them in sandboxes or branches, review diffs thoroughly and keep permissions narrow.
AI coding tools are trained on large amounts of code, and questions about licensing of suggestions and training data are still being debated. Some tools offer settings that filter suggestions matching public code, and some vendors offer intellectual property protections in business plans. For open source projects and commercial software, understand your tool's terms, follow your organisation's policies and be cautious about accepting long suggestions that look copied from elsewhere.
Relying on AI for everything can erode skills, especially for newer developers. Make time to write code without assistance, read documentation directly, debug problems yourself before asking AI and study the code AI produces until you understand it. Experienced developers who use AI well tend to be those who could do the work without it and use AI to go faster, not to replace understanding.
These illustrative examples are not real people.
A computer science student solves problems on her own first, then asks an AI assistant for hints and explanations, and practises without AI before exams.
A web developer uses AI autocomplete for boilerplate and tests, but turns it off when working on a complex payment flow and relies on careful review.
A data analyst who is not a professional programmer uses AI to write small scripts in a language she is learning, and asks for explanations of every line.
These are recurring themes from developer discussions, not quotations from individuals.
The Review NYU is an independent publication. We base these guides on hands-on testing, companies' own documentation and published research. We label company claims as such, do not accept payment for placement and never invent statistics, reviews or credentials. Read about our editorial standards.
Sometimes. A controlled experiment found a 55.8 percent speedup on a well defined task, while a 2025 trial found experienced developers on their own large projects were 19 percent slower with AI. Measure your own results.
Not automatically. Review it, test it and run security checks as you would for any untrusted code, with extra care around authentication and user data.
Yes, as a tutor for hints and explanations, within course rules, while practising without AI to build real skill.
Only if your employer allows it and the tool meets its data requirements. Never paste secrets such as keys or passwords.
AI systems that can plan and make changes across files, run commands and tests, and propose pull requests. Use them on well scoped tasks with narrow permissions.
Because output is often almost right but not quite, which still saves time on some tasks while requiring careful checking.
Yes, sometimes. Check that any API or package exists and is the version you expect before relying on it.
AI is changing how programming is done, but understanding requirements, designing systems, reviewing code and taking responsibility for what ships still require people with real skill.
Consider data handling, admin controls, editor and repository integration, licensing terms and cost. Pilot on real work, measure results and write usage guidelines before a wide rollout.
Keep a short log comparing similar tasks with and without AI, including time spent reviewing and fixing, and watch for bugs that appear later.
Questions about licensing of suggestions and training data are still debated. Understand your tool s terms, use filters for matching public code where available and follow your organisation s policies.
Regularly write and debug code without AI, read documentation directly and make sure you understand any code AI produces before using it.
They can handle well scoped tasks such as dependency updates, simple bug fixes and test writing. Run them in branches or sandboxes, keep permissions narrow and review every diff before merging, especially on production systems.
This guide is independent and editorially reviewed. Company claims are labelled as such, and we never invent statistics, reviews or credentials. Read about The Review, our editorial standards, or contact us.