Slow cookers look alike, but independent testers keep finding that many newer models run too hot, boiling food even on Low. We compared what three outlets' hands-on tests found and checked current prices for each pick.
The Review NYU is not affiliated with New York University.
We do not currently earn a commission from any link on this page. If links ever become affiliate links, we will label them clearly.
Short answer. For most kitchens, the Cuisinart Cook Central 3-in-1 6-quart ($83.85 at Amazon, checked 12 November 2026) is the safest choice. It is the only cooker Bon Appétit recommended after testing 13, and it can sear in the pot. For a temperature probe, consider the Hamilton Beach Set & Forget 6-quart ($83.47). On a budget, Food Network's pick is the Crock-Pot 7-quart manual ($44.99). For small households, look at the Brentwood 1.5-quart ($20.99), Serious Eats' mini pick, or the Instant Pot Rio Mini ($89.95). Testers disagree on Crock-Pot's programmable models, so check the Low setting with a thermometer after you buy.
The Review NYU did not test any slow cookers for this guide. Nothing here comes from our own kitchen. We read the published hands-on testing of three outlets and summarized where they agree and where they split: Serious Eats, Bon Appétit (13 models tested, last updated August 2026) and Food Network, both its full-size slow cooker guide (13 models, updated 12 August 2026) and its mini slow cooker guide (15 models, updated 3 November 2026).
Serious Eats' page could not be retrieved in full with our research tools, so we only use the picks its own published summary names: the Crock-Pot Programmable 6-Quart as best overall and the Brentwood 1.5-Quart as best mini. We do not repeat test details from that page that we could not read. For background on food safety we used the USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service's slow cooker guidance.
Prices were checked on 12 November 2026 on Amazon.com product pages and on maker sites (Hamilton Beach and Crock-Pot). Retail prices change often, especially around Black Friday. Treat them as a snapshot, not a quote.
What we weighted most, in line with what the testers measured: whether the Low setting stays below a boil, how fast food gets out of the bacterial "danger zone," and whether vegetables come out intact rather than mushy. Ease of use, cleanup and portability came next.
| Model | Capacity | Type | Who backs it | Price checked | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cuisinart Cook Central 3-in-1 (MSC-600) | 6 qt | Slow cooker plus brown/sauté and steam | Bon Appétit top pick | $83.85 | Most households; searing in the same pot |
| Hamilton Beach Set & Forget 6-Qt (33969AG) | 6 qt | Programmable, probe, clip lid | Food Network "Another Favorite"; Bon Appétit "liked but didn't love" | $83.47 | Large cuts of meat cooked to a target temperature |
| Crock-Pot 7-Qt Oval Manual | 7 qt | Manual dial (Low/High/Warm) | Food Network Best Budget | $44.99 (list $59.99) | Tight budgets; people at home while it cooks |
| Crock-Pot 6-Qt Cook & Carry Programmable | 6 qt | Programmable, locking lid | Food Network Best Portable; Bon Appétit did not recommend | $76.61 (third-party seller; list $94.99) | Potlucks and tailgates |
| Crock-Pot MultiMeal | 2 x 3.7 qt | Dual-pot multicooker | Food Network Best Dual-Sided | $144.99 (list $151.99) | Main and side at the same time |
| Instant Pot Rio Mini 4-Qt | 4 qt | Pressure cooker/multicooker | Food Network mini guide Best Overall | $89.95 | Small kitchens that want one appliance |
| Hamilton Beach Set & Forget 4-Qt | 4 qt | Programmable (2-hour steps) | Food Network mini guide Best Programmable | $49.95 | Couples and small families |
| Brentwood SC-115 1.5-Qt | 1.5 qt | Manual mini | Serious Eats Best Mini | $20.99 | One person, dips, small batches |
Serious Eats' overall winner, the Crock-Pot Programmable 6-Quart with a probe, is not priced in this table. Crock-Pot sells several programmable 6-quart models, and we could not confirm from Serious Eats' published summary which exact model number it tested. Crock-Pot's own probe-equipped 6-quart, the Programmable 6-Quart Slow Cooker with Sous Vide (CPSCRTO60-OM), showed as out of stock with no price on crock-pot.com when we checked.
Bon Appétit named this its single recommended slow cooker after testing 13 models. Its testers cooked a green chicken chili on High for four hours and on Low for six, and logged water temperatures hourly. They reported "batch after batch of succulent chicken and tender stewed vegetables." Per Bon Appétit, the preset temperatures are 185°F for simmer, 200°F for Low and 212°F for High. A brown/sauté mode reached 350°F in about six minutes, so you can sear in the same pot. A steam mode and rack are included, and the timer runs up to 24 hours.
The drawbacks Bon Appétit lists are real. The lid does not lock, which matters if you carry food to parties. The insert is aluminum with a PTFE-based nonstick coating rather than stoneware. Amazon showed it at $83.85 on 12 November 2026 with "only 1 left in stock." Bon Appétit's page listed it at $129, so check before you buy. Our guide to telling whether a sale is a real deal explains how to read swings like that.
This model's selling point is a thermometer probe. You set a target internal temperature, and the cooker switches to Warm when the meat reaches it. Food Network's testers called that a fix for "one of the biggest risks associated with slow cooking," which is overcooked food. They also liked the clip-down lid for travel. Their main complaint was that the probe can be hard to insert accurately.
Bon Appétit was cooler on it. Its testers found "negligible" difference between probe and non-probe cookers in their results. They also flagged a dim display and an exterior that got hot enough to make carrying it uncomfortable. On 12 November 2026, Amazon (sold by Amazon.com) listed the 33969AG at $83.47. Hamilton Beach's own site showed the 33969A and 33969AG at $69.99 but out of stock.
Food Network chose this plain dial model (Low, High, Warm) as its budget pick and said it made "super tender beef paprikash." There is no timer and no automatic shut-off. Food Network frames that as suiting someone who is home while the food cooks. It was $44.99 at Amazon on 12 November 2026, against a $59.99 list price.
There is one caution from Bon Appétit's testing of a different manual Crock-Pot, the 6-quart Cook & Carry with a knob. On Low, that cooker held food at about 125°F after two hours and reached 170°F only by the four-hour mark. That is slower than Bon Appétit wanted for raw meat. Food Network did not report the same problem with the 7-quart oval, but the two outlets did not test the same unit.
The Crock-Pot brand is where the outlets disagree most.
Serious Eats picked a Crock-Pot Programmable 6-Quart as its best overall and described it as "affordable, simple to operate," with a probe. Food Network named the Crock-Pot 6-Quart Cook & Carry Programmable its best portable cooker. It praised the gasketed locking lid and reported that the outside never went above 87°F during testing, while some other cookers passed 125°F. Food Network also placed it runner-up overall for meat tenderness.
Bon Appétit tested the Crock-Pot Programmable 6-Quart Cook & Carry and did not recommend it. Its testers found the Low setting "calibrated to reach 212°" rather than staying in a 170–190°F window. Meat came out fine, but vegetables were overcooked at the recommended times. A 7-quart Crock-Pot with sous vide had similar problems in Bon Appétit's tests: it cooked at 212°F for the last two hours on High and reached a simmer on Low by hour six.
How to read that: running hot on Low is the complaint to watch for with any programmable cooker, not only Crock-Pots. Bon Appétit found the same pattern in the Ninja PossibleCooker Pro on High and in a Chefman 7-quart on both settings. If you buy a programmable model, run a water test during the return window. Fill the crock halfway, set Low and check with a thermometer after a few hours. Our guide on testing a product during the return window covers the rest. On 12 November 2026, Amazon listed the Cook & Carry at $76.61 from a third-party seller ("810 trade"), against a $94.99 list price.
Tip: Bon Appétit's benchmark, which cites Michigan State University Extension, is that Low should peak around 185°F and stay below 212°F. If your water is at a rolling boil on Low, expect mushy vegetables.
"Multicooker" covers two different kinds of appliance, and testers treat them differently.
The Cuisinart Cook Central (above) is mainly a slow cooker that can also sear and steam. Food Network's dual-pot pick, the Crock-Pot MultiMeal, has two separately programmable 3.7-quart nonstick pots. Each pot can slow cook, bake, rice/steam, sear/sauté or keep warm. Its SyncFinish feature staggers start times so both dishes finish together. Food Network liked it for cooking a stew and beans at the same time. Its downsides: there is no single large pot, so it can't take large recipes, and the inserts are not stoneware. Amazon listed it at $144.99 on 12 November 2026.
Testers are more doubtful here. Bon Appétit left Instant Pots out of its slow cooker review because recipes written for slow cookers "don't always translate well" to them. Food Network's main guide says it does not recommend using an Instant Pot as a slow cooker. In its testing, the slow-cook function heated unevenly and food burned on the bottom.
Food Network's own mini guide reached a different verdict on a smaller model. It named the Instant Pot Rio Mini 4-Quart its best mini overall, saying it "did a great job as a slow cooker" and held a fairly steady temperature. It also liked the countdown timer and the in-pot sauté. On the downside, it takes up as much counter space as a 6-quart Instant Pot, and food stuck to the stainless pot. Our reading is that a pressure cooker is a reasonable choice if you want one appliance that also slow cooks. If slow cooking is your main use, a dedicated slow cooker is the safer choice. Amazon listed the Rio Mini at $89.95 on 12 November 2026.
Small cookers suit one or two people, side dishes and party dips.
Serious Eats names this its best mini slow cooker. We could not read Serious Eats' test notes on it, so we only report the pick. Amazon's listing describes a 1.5-quart ceramic crock for "2 to 3 people," three settings (low, high, auto), a dishwasher-safe crock and glass lid, and a 115-watt rating. The white SC-115W was $20.99 at Amazon (sold by Amazon.com) on 12 November 2026.
Food Network's mini guide called this its best programmable small cooker. Testers praised the oval crock for easy serving, the automatic switch to Warm and the wide handles. Its limit is the timer: Hamilton Beach's listing confirms you choose 2, 4, 6, 8 or 10 hours, and there is no countdown. Food Network ran its mini cookers through queso, frozen meatballs heated to 160°F and oatmeal tests. Amazon listed this model at $49.95 on 12 November 2026.
Food Network also picked a two-pack of 2-quart Beautiful by Drew cookers as best value and the Crock-Pot 2.5-Quart Casserole as best for potlucks. The casserole has a locking lid, but its queso scorched a little on one side after 1.5 hours on Low. It also picked a KOOC 2-quart for dips. We did not verify current prices for these, so they are not in the table.
One expensive model gets mixed verdicts. Food Network's best overall is the All-Clad Gourmet Plus 7-Quart, which it listed at $350 at Williams-Sonoma. Its testers said it produced "the most-tender meat overall" and held a steady temperature. Bon Appétit did not recommend the All-Clad Gourmet: its testers called it "huge, expensive, and heavy" and said its lid sealed poorly. We could not confirm a current price for the exact Gourmet Plus model. If you're comparing listings, our guide to reading a spec sheet can help.
The USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service says slow cookers generally cook between 170°F and 280°F, and that the heat, long cooking time and steam together destroy bacteria. Its main rules:
Food Network adds that most makers advise filling the crock at least halfway. Food in a crock below that line can finish one to two hours early.
There is no consensus. Bon Appétit recommends only the Cuisinart Cook Central 6-quart, Serious Eats picks a Crock-Pot Programmable 6-Quart with a probe, and Food Network picks the All-Clad Gourmet Plus 7-quart. For most people the Cuisinart is the safest bet on price and test results.
Crock-Pot is a brand of slow cooker, and the name is often used for the whole category. Other brands, including Cuisinart and Hamilton Beach, did as well or better than Crock-Pot models in independent tests.
Bon Appétit measured several programmable models, including Crock-Pots, reaching 212°F, a boil, even on Low. That overcooks vegetables. A water test with a thermometer during the return window will show how your unit behaves.
It works, but testers are mixed. Food Network's main guide found uneven heating and burning, while its mini guide rated the Instant Pot Rio Mini's slow-cook mode well. If slow cooking is your main use, a dedicated slow cooker is the safer choice.
A 6- to 7-quart cooker suits families and large roasts. Hamilton Beach says its 6-quart fits a 6 lb chicken or 4 lb roast. A 4-quart serves about four, and 1.5- to 2-quart minis suit one or two people or dips.
The USDA says to always thaw meat or poultry first. The exception is a cooker built for it, such as Hamilton Beach's Defrost model, used exactly as its instructions say.