Best winter tires of 2026: what Tire Rack's test says about ice, snow and wet roads

Tire Rack's 2026 winter test found no single best tire: one model led on ice, another on snow and a third on wet roads. Here is what the numbers show, which tire suits your winters, and which tested models have since been replaced.

The Review NYU is not affiliated with New York University.

We do not currently earn a commission from any link on this page. If links ever become affiliate links, we will label them clearly.

Short answer. In Tire Rack's 2026 winter test (215/55R17, 2025 Toyota Camry), the Bridgestone Blizzak WS90 was best on ice, the Michelin X-Ice Snow stopped shortest on snow, and the Vredestein Wintrac Pro+ was the best winter tire on wet roads but weakest on ice, according to Tyre Reviews, which republished the data with Tire Rack. Note that the WS90 is being replaced by the Blizzak IcePeak and the tested X-Ice Snow by the X-Ice Snow+; neither newer tire was in the test.

How we judged

The Review NYU did not test any tires. This guide is built on Tire Rack's 2026 winter test, which ran ten tires in size 215/55R17 on a 2025 Toyota Camry: five dedicated winter tires, three all-weather tires with the three-peak mountain snowflake marking and two all-season tires without it. We could not load Tire Rack's own pages on 21 November 2026 (both its best winter tires page and the original test report returned an error page to our reader), so the measured figures below come from Tyre Reviews, which republished the test data in partnership with Tire Rack and converted it to metric. The results are Tire Rack's; the conversions are Tyre Reviews'.

Tire Rack brakes from different speeds on each surface: 50 mph on dry and wet pavement, 25 mph on snow and 12 mph on ice, according to Tyre Reviews. That means a snow distance cannot be compared with an ice distance; only compare tires within the same test. Tire Rack does not name a single overall winner. It publishes separate road and snow ratings, and Tyre Reviews' ranking order combines the two evenly.

We then checked product names and status with the makers. That step changed the story: two of the three tires in the original brief have been replaced or updated since the test tires were built. We separate what Tire Rack measured from what manufacturers claim, and we have marked every maker claim as such. We did not verify prices because Tire Rack's site would not load for us, so there are no prices in this guide.

First, a name check: X-Ice Snow vs X-Ice Snow+, WS90 vs IcePeak

The tire Tire Rack tested was the Michelin X-Ice Snow, not the X-Ice Snow+. Tyre Reviews lists the tested tire as the X-Ice Snow and notes it has been replaced by the Michelin X-Ice Snow+. Michelin's US site does sell a tire called the Michelin X-Ice Snow+ (written with the plus sign), and labels it new. So the name in the original brief exists, but the test numbers belong to its predecessor.

Michelin's own comparison, run by a third party for Michelin in size 235/55R19 on an Audi Q5, rates the X-Ice Snow+ against the old X-Ice Snow at 103.8% for ice braking, 101.3% for snow braking, 113.8% for wet braking and 107.2% for dry braking, with the old tire as 100% (Michelin legal notes). Those are maker claims, not Tire Rack results. If they hold up in independent testing, the Snow+ should fix some of the wet-road weakness Tire Rack measured in the older tire.

The Bridgestone Blizzak WS90 was tested and won the ice tests, but Bridgestone says its new Blizzak IcePeak replaces both the Blizzak WS90 and the Blizzak DM-V2, with a national launch in May 2026 in 107 sizes from 14 to 22 inches. In practice the WS90 is now a run-out model: you may still find it, but stock and sizes will shrink. Bridgestone says the IcePeak uses an optimized version of the same winter compounds as the WS90 and carries both the 3PMSF and Ice Grip symbols (Bridgestone press release). Tire Rack's test did not include the IcePeak, so we cannot tell you how it compares.

The Vredestein Wintrac Pro+ is the name used in the test and on Tyre Reviews, which describes it as a dedicated performance winter tire.

The picks from Tire Rack's 2026 winter test

Best on ice: Bridgestone Blizzak WS90 (now being replaced by the Blizzak IcePeak)

In Tire Rack's test the WS90 was the strongest tire where grip was scarcest. It recorded the shortest ice braking distance (11.80 m), the quickest ice acceleration (5.02 s), the fastest snow handling lap (53.66 s) and the highest subjective snow score (8.25 points), per the Tyre Reviews write-up of the data. It also stopped shortest of the winter tires on dry pavement (28.07 m).

The trade-off is steering and wet grip. Testers found its steering lost sharpness once loaded in a corner, and its wet cornering grip tied for lowest in the test (0.60 g). Wet braking was 35.84 m, 5.30 m longer than the Wintrac Pro+ (Tyre Reviews). Because Bridgestone is replacing it with the IcePeak, check what is actually in stock in your size.

Best for snow braking and steering: Michelin X-Ice Snow (successor: X-Ice Snow+)

The X-Ice Snow had the shortest snow braking distance in the test (17.10 m) and finished a close second on ice, both in braking (12.01 m, 0.21 m behind the WS90) and acceleration (5.09 s). Testers rated its steering and road handling second of all ten tires, behind only the Michelin CrossClimate2 all-weather tire, which Tyre Reviews calls unusual for a studless ice tire.

Its weakness was clear roads. It was last of the ten for dry braking (31.39 m), wet braking (39.32 m) and tied last for wet cornering (Tyre Reviews). The newer X-Ice Snow+ is what you will find for sale; Michelin claims better braking on every surface and a 45,000-mile treadwear warranty (Michelin), but no independent test of the Snow+ was part of this review.

Best for mostly wet, cold roads: Vredestein Wintrac Pro+

The Wintrac Pro+ had the best wet performance of any winter tire in the test: 30.54 m wet braking and 0.71 g wet cornering. It was 5.30 m shorter in the wet than the next winter tire and braked better in the wet than two of the non-winter tires. It was also one of the most comfortable tires (7.75 points) and second-best winter tire in the dry (28.19 m) (Tyre Reviews).

On ice it was the weakest winter tire: 16.22 m ice braking, 4.42 m longer than the WS90, and the slowest winter tire for ice acceleration (6.02 s). It was even beaten on ice by Vredestein's own Quatrac all-weather tire. It also finished last of the winter tires for snow braking (19.23 m) and snow handling (57.07 s). Tyre Reviews sums it up as a sensible fit for milder winters and faster roads.

Best all-rounder for comfort: Continental VikingContact 8

Not in the original brief, but worth naming: the VikingContact 8 finished first of the winter tires in Tyre Reviews' combined order of Tire Rack's road and snow ratings. It was the most comfortable tire in the test (8 points) and the quietest winter tire (7.75 points), with third place for both snow braking (18.08 m) and ice braking (13.20 m). Its weak spots were wet braking (35.91 m) and dry braking (30.15 m) (Tyre Reviews).

All-weather alternative: Bridgestone WeatherPeak

The WeatherPeak stopped in 17.87 m on snow, beating three of the five dedicated winter tires, including the VikingContact 8 and Wintrac Pro+. On ice the gap reopened: 16.49 m, 4.69 m longer than the WS90. It was also rated the least comfortable tire in the test (Tyre Reviews).

Tire Rack's measured results, side by side

Lower is better in every column. Braking distances are in metres; lap and acceleration times are in seconds. Remember that each surface uses a different starting speed, so compare down a column, not across a row.

TireDry braking (m)Wet braking (m)Snow braking (m)Snow lap (s)Ice braking (m)Ice acceleration (s)
Bridgestone Blizzak WS9028.0735.8417.4753.6611.805.02
Michelin X-Ice Snow31.3939.3217.1054.3112.015.09
Continental VikingContact 830.1535.9118.0854.1913.205.30
General Altimax Arctic 12 (unstudded)31.3037.3118.6256.3113.995.51
Vredestein Wintrac Pro+28.1930.5419.2357.0716.226.02
Bridgestone WeatherPeak (all-weather)29.4433.7417.8758.0416.496.17

Data: Tire Rack 2026 winter test, 215/55R17 on a 2025 Toyota Camry, as republished and converted to metric by Tyre Reviews, read on 21 November 2026.

Two patterns stand out. First, the studless ice tires (WS90, X-Ice Snow) are the clear leaders on ice and packed snow and the weakest on wet pavement. Second, the spread is largest exactly where the danger is highest: Tyre Reviews notes the best winter tire stopped in a little under 12 m on ice while the weakest all-season tire needed almost 18 m (Tyre Reviews).

Which tire for ice, deep snow or mostly wet roads

Mostly ice, black ice and freezing rain

Pick a studless ice tire. In this test that means the Blizzak WS90 (11.80 m ice braking) or the Michelin X-Ice Snow (12.01 m), a gap of only 0.21 m. Since the WS90 is being replaced, the practical shortlist today is whatever WS90 stock remains, the Blizzak IcePeak (untested here) or the X-Ice Snow+ (untested here, but Michelin claims 3.8% better ice braking than the tested X-Ice Snow, per Michelin). Avoid relying on the Wintrac Pro+ for ice: it braked 4.42 m longer than the WS90.

Deep snow and unplowed roads

Be careful here: Tire Rack's snow tests were braking, a handling lap and subjective ratings on a prepared snow surface, not a deep-snow test. On that surface, the X-Ice Snow stopped shortest (17.10 m) and the WS90 set the fastest lap (53.66 s) and highest snow score (Tyre Reviews). Either is a sound choice. Michelin also claims the X-Ice Snow+ has better deep-snow start-up traction than three competitors, but that is a maker claim from its own commissioned tests (Michelin). If you regularly drive through fresh, unplowed snow, ground clearance and driving technique matter as much as the tire.

Mostly wet, cold roads with occasional snow

The Vredestein Wintrac Pro+ is the best fit among the winter tires. It braked 8.78 m shorter in the wet than the X-Ice Snow and 5.30 m shorter than the WS90, and had the highest wet cornering grip of the winter group (Tyre Reviews). If your winters are mostly rain near freezing with a few snow days and little ice, an all-weather tire may also make sense (see below).

A quick rule of thumb

  • Ice is your main worry: studless ice tire (Blizzak WS90 or its replacement, or Michelin X-Ice Snow+).
  • Lots of snow, some ice, want sharper steering: Michelin X-Ice Snow+.
  • Want a quiet, comfortable winter tire: Continental VikingContact 8.
  • Mostly wet roads, faster highway driving: Vredestein Wintrac Pro+.
  • Mild winters, no second set of wheels: a 3PMSF all-weather tire.

3PMSF vs M+S: what the sidewall symbols mean

The three-peak mountain snowflake (3PMSF) symbol is a performance mark. Under the U.S. Tire Manufacturers Association definition for passenger and light-truck tires, a tire qualifies only if it reaches a minimum snow grip index against a standard reference test tire in the ASTM F1805 snow traction test on medium-packed snow: at least 1.10 against the 14-inch reference tire, or 1.12 against the 16-inch one (USTMA Tire Information Service Bulletin Vol. 37 No. 6). The same bulletin sets the symbol's look: three peaks with the middle one tallest, a six-sided snowflake inside, at least 15 mm wide and tall, placed next to the M+S marking.

M+S (mud and snow) on its own is an older and weaker marking that does not require this snow traction result. The USTMA bulletin describes 3PMSF tires as giving superior snow performance over tires that only meet the basic USTMA snow tire definition (USTMA).

Two limits matter. The 3PMSF qualification is a snow traction test, so it says nothing about ice. And 3PMSF appears on all-weather tires too, not only on winter tires. Tire Rack's test shows how big the ice gap can be even between 3PMSF tires: the Vredestein Quatrac all-weather tire stopped in 15.42 m on ice, while the WS90 stopped in 11.80 m (Tyre Reviews). A separate Ice Grip symbol, based on an ISO ice braking test, now appears on some tires; Bridgestone says it requires at least 18% better ice braking than a standard reference tire (Bridgestone), and both the X-Ice Snow+ and IcePeak carry it, according to their makers.

Studless vs studdable winter tires

Studless winter tires, such as the Blizzak WS90 and Michelin X-Ice Snow, get their ice grip from soft tread compounds and many small slits (sipes) rather than metal studs. Bridgestone, for example, credits its MultiCell compound and 3D sipes for the Blizzak line's ice grip (Bridgestone). They are what most drivers in cities and suburbs buy.

Studdable tires have molded holes so a shop can fit metal studs. The General Altimax Arctic 12 in Tire Rack's test is one; it was run without studs and still finished mid-pack among the winter tires and clearly ahead of the all-season tires on ice (Tyre Reviews). Studs can add bite on hard ice, but they are noisier on dry pavement, and stud use is restricted by season or banned in some US states, so check your state's rules before you buy studs. We did not test or review studded performance in this guide.

For most drivers in places like the New York area, where roads are plowed and salted and ice comes and goes, a good studless tire is the usual choice. Drivers who face long stretches of hard-packed ice may consider studs if their state allows them.

When an all-weather tire is enough

All-weather tires carry the 3PMSF symbol but are designed to stay on the car all year. In Tire Rack's test they were much better than all-season tires in winter and close to winter tires on snow, but still well behind on ice. The best all-weather tire on ice, the Vredestein Quatrac, needed 15.42 m to stop; the WS90 needed 11.80 m. On snow, the WeatherPeak (17.87 m) beat three winter tires (Tyre Reviews).

Tyre Reviews' verdict on the Michelin CrossClimate2 captures the trade-off: excellent for drivers who see occasional winter weather, not a substitute where winter is a season. Michelin itself recommends four dedicated winter tires for severe winter conditions (Michelin FAQ).

An all-weather tire makes sense if you see a few snow days a year, rarely face ice, do not want to store a second set of tires, and value dry and wet grip. Choose dedicated winter tires if you drive regularly on ice or snow, commute early in the morning before roads are treated, or live in hilly areas. The all-season tires in the test without 3PMSF were weakest of all in winter conditions, so they are not a sensible winter choice where snow is routine.

Other cold-weather gear guides from The Review NYU: how to choose a winter jacket and the best hand warmers.

Bottom line

Tire Rack's 2026 test backs the brief's three tires, each for a different kind of winter. The Bridgestone Blizzak WS90 was the best on ice and the best snow handler. The Michelin X-Ice Snow stopped shortest on snow and steered best of the winter tires. The Vredestein Wintrac Pro+ was the clear choice for wet, cold roads but the weakest winter tire on ice (Tyre Reviews, using Tire Rack data).

The catch is timing. The WS90 is being replaced by the Blizzak IcePeak, and the X-Ice Snow has been replaced by the X-Ice Snow+. Neither new tire was in this test. If ice is your main problem, a studless ice tire from Bridgestone or Michelin is still the evidence-backed choice. If your winters are mostly rain, the Wintrac Pro+ or a good 3PMSF all-weather tire is the more sensible buy.

Limits of this article

  • The Review NYU did not test any tires hands-on. This guide is research based and relies on Tire Rack's published test data.
  • Tire Rack's own pages (its best winter tires page and the original test report) returned an error page to our reader on 21 November 2026, so we used Tyre Reviews' republication of the data, which Tyre Reviews says was produced in partnership with Tire Rack. Figures are Tyre Reviews' metric conversions of Tire Rack's imperial results.
  • Prices are not included because we could not load Tire Rack's product pages to verify a price today.
  • The tested Michelin X-Ice Snow has been replaced by the X-Ice Snow+, and the Blizzak WS90 is being replaced by the Blizzak IcePeak. Neither newer tire was part of this test; claims about them come from the manufacturers.
  • Tire Rack tested one size (215/55R17) on one car. Results can differ in other sizes and on other vehicles, and the test did not include deep, unplowed snow or studded tires.
  • No product images are shown because we do not have licensed photos.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

What is the best winter tire for ice in 2026?

In Tire Rack's 2026 test the Bridgestone Blizzak WS90 had the shortest ice braking distance (11.80 m) and quickest ice acceleration, with the Michelin X-Ice Snow 0.21 m behind. The WS90 is being replaced by the Blizzak IcePeak, which was not in the test.

Is it the Michelin X-Ice Snow or X-Ice Snow+?

Both exist. Tire Rack's 2026 test used the Michelin X-Ice Snow. Michelin now sells the newer X-Ice Snow+, which Michelin says brakes better on ice, snow, wet and dry roads than the older tire. Those improvements are maker claims, not Tire Rack results.

Which winter tire is best for mostly wet roads?

Among the winter tires Tire Rack tested, the Vredestein Wintrac Pro+ had the shortest wet braking distance and the highest wet cornering grip. It was the weakest winter tire on ice, so it suits milder, wetter winters.

What is the difference between 3PMSF and M+S?

The three-peak mountain snowflake symbol means a tire passed a minimum snow traction test against a reference tire under the USTMA definition. M+S alone is an older marking that does not require that snow test. Neither symbol covers ice performance.

Are all-weather tires as good as winter tires?

Not on ice. In Tire Rack's test the best all-weather tire needed 15.42 m to stop on ice versus 11.80 m for the best winter tire, although one all-weather tire beat three winter tires in snow braking. They suit mild winters with occasional snow.

Should I buy studless or studdable winter tires?

Most drivers on plowed and salted roads choose studless tires, which grip ice through soft compounds and sipes. Studdable tires can take metal studs for hard ice, but studs are noisy on dry pavement and are restricted in some states, so check local rules first.