How to choose an e-reader: screen size, lighting, waterproofing, ecosystems and library books

The screen gets the attention, but the store and library system behind an e-reader decide whether you are still happy with it in three years. Here is what to compare, with every rule sourced.

The Review NYU is not affiliated with New York University.

We do not currently earn a commission from any link on this page. If links ever become affiliate links, we will label them clearly.

Short answer. Decide on the ecosystem first: Kindle library loans through Libby are U.S. only, while newer Kobo readers have OverDrive/Libby built in in 13 listed countries. Then look for about 300 ppi for text, adjustable warm light for night reading, and an IPX8 rating with the maker's stated depth and time (Kobo quotes 60 minutes in up to 2 metres) if you read near water. Color E Ink shows color at 150 ppi versus 300 ppi for text, so choose it only for comics or illustrated books, and pay for a stylus only if you will write.

How we judged

The Review NYU did not handle or test any e-reader for this guide. It is a research-based buying guide: we read the help pages that govern library lending (OverDrive/Libby, Amazon and Kobo), a standards explainer for IP water ratings, and the current spec pages of three makers (Amazon, Kobo and Boox), all on 21 November 2026. Every number below comes from one of those pages and is linked where it appears.

Two rules shaped the advice. First, maker claims are treated as claims: a footnote that says "up to 40 days" of battery is a lab scenario chosen by the maker, not a measurement we or an independent reviewer made. Second, the things that decide whether you are happy in year three, such as where your books live and whether your library card works on the device, get more weight than the things that look good on a box. If you want a refresher on reading spec sheets with that skepticism, see our guide on how to read a product spec sheet.

We left out prices from third-party retailers because we could not check them consistently today, and we mention specific models only as examples of a spec, not as picks.

Start with where your books will come from

Most e-reader advice starts with screens. We think it should start with books, because the store and library system you pick is the part that is hardest to undo. Ask yourself three questions before looking at any hardware:

  • Do you already own a library of ebooks? If you have years of purchases in one store, a device from the same company is the path of least friction. Store-bought ebooks are generally tied to the account and app of the store that sold them, so switching brands usually means leaving those books behind or reading them on a phone.
  • Do you borrow from a public library? Library support differs by brand and by country, and this is the most common surprise for new owners. It gets its own section below.
  • Do you read files from other sources? DRM-free EPUBs from small publishers, PDFs from work or school, or comics in CBZ format all behave differently depending on the device.

Once you know your answers, the field narrows quickly. Then screen, light and waterproofing decide which model in that ecosystem fits.

Screen size and sharpness (ppi)

E-reader screens are measured diagonally, like phones. The common sizes today are 6 inches for the smallest, pocketable models, around 7 inches for the mid-size readers with page-turn buttons, and 8 inches or larger for models aimed at PDFs and note-taking. Amazon describes its smallest current model as a 6-inch Kindle, while Kobo's Libra Colour and Boox's Go 7 are both 7-inch devices.

What size actually changes

  • 6 inches: lightest and easiest to hold one-handed or carry in a coat pocket. Fine for novels; cramped for PDFs, textbooks and comics.
  • 7 inches: more words per page so fewer page turns, and room for physical page-turn buttons. For reference, Kobo lists the Libra Colour at 199.5 g and Boox lists the Go 7 at approximately 195 g.
  • 8 inches and up: better for fixed-layout documents and handwriting, but heavier and usually more expensive. PDFs do not reflow like ebooks, so a small screen forces zooming and panning.

Pixels per inch

Sharpness is quoted in pixels per inch (ppi). For black-and-white text, 300 ppi has become the reference point among current mid-range and premium readers: Kobo quotes 300 ppi for black-and-white content on the Libra Colour and Boox quotes 300 ppi for the monochrome Go 7. Higher ppi makes small fonts and non-Latin scripts crisper; at normal reading distance, most people notice the jump from older low-resolution screens more than differences above 300.

The catch is color, which we cover below: on today's color E Ink screens, the color layer is half as sharp as the text layer.

Front light and warm light

E Ink screens reflect ambient light like paper, which is why they stay readable in sunlight. To read in the dark they use a front light that shines across the screen surface rather than a backlight that shines through it. Practically every current reader has one; the differences are in the details.

Battery figures are tied to light settings. Kobo, for example, says a single charge lasts up to 40 days, based on 30 minutes of reading per day with the front light at 30% brightness and wireless off. Read those footnotes: brighter light, more reading per day or Bluetooth audio will shorten that.

Color E Ink: what you gain and what you give up

Color E Ink has gone mainstream. Amazon sells the Kindle Colorsoft, Kobo sells the Libra Colour and Clara Colour, and Boox sells the Go Color 7 (Gen II). Color makes book covers, comics, children's books, maps, charts and colored highlights more useful. It also comes with real trade-offs.

SpecKobo Libra ColourBoox Go Color 7 (Gen II)Boox Go 7 (monochrome)
Screen7" E Ink Kaleido 37" Kaleido 37" HD ePaper (Carta 1300)
Resolution1264 x 16801680 x 12641680 x 1264
Black-and-white sharpness300 ppi300 ppi300 ppi
Color sharpness150 ppi150 ppiNo color

Source: maker spec pages for the Kobo Libra Colour and Boox Go 7 series, read 21 November 2026. Maker claims, not measured by The Review NYU.

The pattern in that table is the key point: on Kaleido 3 screens, color content is shown at half the ppi of black-and-white content. Colors also look muted compared with a phone or tablet, closer to a newspaper print than a glossy magazine. Boox notes in a footnote that its color screen's front light may generate a tiny side shadow. If you read mostly text-only novels, a monochrome screen gives you the sharpest result for the money. If you read comics, illustrated nonfiction or like color highlighting, color is worth considering, ideally after seeing one in person or within a return window.

Waterproofing and what IPX ratings mean

Water ratings follow the IP (Ingress Protection) code defined in the IEC 60529 family of standards. The format is "IP" followed by two characters: the first is protection against solids such as dust, the second against water. An "X" means that category was not rated. So IPX8 says nothing about dust and only describes water resistance. This explainer from RS summarizes the scale; we could not load the IEC's own page today.

If you read in the bath, by the pool or at the beach, choose an IPX8 model and check the maker's depth and time figures. Ratings are tested with fresh water in lab conditions, so treat salt water and chlorinated pools with caution and rinse the device afterwards if the maker's instructions allow it.

Store ecosystems, file formats and DRM lock-in

The three most visible ecosystems work in different ways:

Amazon Kindle

Kindles are built around the Kindle Store. For your own files, Amazon's Send to Kindle service accepts PDF, DOC, DOCX, TXT, RTF, HTM, HTML, PNG, GIF, JPG, JPEG, BMP and EPUB, with a maximum file size of 200 MB, through the web, phone apps, email, a Chrome extension and desktop apps. That covers DRM-free EPUBs, but the files go through Amazon's service rather than being read natively the way a Kobo or Boox opens them.

Kobo

Kobo devices use the Kobo Store but also open many file types directly. Kobo lists 15 file formats supported natively on the Libra Colour, including EPUB, EPUB3, PDF, MOBI, TXT, HTML, RTF, CBZ and CBR. On the Libra Colour, Kobo also lists Dropbox and Google Drive connections, according to its product page.

Boox and other Android readers

Boox devices run Android with the Google Play Store built in; the Go 7 series ships with Android 13 and supports 26 digital formats, including EPUB, AZW3, MOBI, PDF, DJVU, CBZ and DOCX. Because you can install apps from Google Play, you can in principle use several bookstores' reading apps on one device. The trade-off is that third-party apps are not designed for E Ink, and we did not check how well any given app behaves on these screens.

What DRM means for you

Most commercial ebooks carry DRM (copy protection) that ties them to the seller's account and apps. Kobo's own help pages distinguish between protected books and non-protected PDF and ePub files you can add yourself, and OverDrive tells owners of older Kobo readers to transfer library ebooks from a computer using Adobe Digital Editions, the software that handles protected library files. In practice: whatever store you buy from, plan on reading those books on that store's devices and apps for as long as you own them.

Library book support: the biggest difference between brands

Many public libraries lend ebooks through OverDrive's Libby. How that reaches your e-reader depends on the brand and where you live.

Device familyHow library ebooks arriveWhere it works
Kindle e-readersBorrow in Libby, tap "Read With... Kindle", finish on Amazon's siteU.S. only
Newer Kobo e-readersOverDrive/Libby built in; borrow and place holds on the device13 listed countries, including the U.S., Canada, U.K., Australia and New Zealand
Older Kobo readers (earlier Aura, Touch 2.0, Glo)Download on a computer and transfer with Adobe Digital EditionsDepends on library

Sources: Libby Help: Reading Kindle Books on a Kindle ereader, Kobo Help: Borrow eBooks from the public library, OverDrive Help: How to borrow OverDrive ebooks on your Kobo ereader, all read 21 November 2026.

Kindle

Libby's help page says you can read most Libby books on a Kindle e-reader, available in the U.S. only. The process sends you to Amazon's website to tap "Get Library Book", after which the book appears on devices linked to your Amazon account. Outside the U.S., Kindle e-readers are not a good fit for library borrowing through Libby.

Kobo

OverDrive points Kobo owners to Kobo's own help site for the list of compatible devices. That page says the built-in feature works in Canada, the United States, the United Kingdom, Australia, New Zealand, Denmark, Finland, Norway, Sweden, Taiwan, Hong Kong, Singapore and Thailand, and lists the compatible models, from the Libra Colour, Clara Colour, Clara BW, Elipsa 2E and Sage back to older ones such as the Clara HD and Aura ONE. You link your library card in the Kobo account, then browse, borrow and place holds from the reader itself. Kobo also warns that some library titles may not be available from Kobo, and vice versa.

Everyone else

For older Kobo models, OverDrive's route is to borrow on a computer and transfer with Adobe Digital Editions. It works, but it is clumsier than borrowing on the device. Android-based readers such as Boox can install apps from Google Play, which in principle includes Libby, but we did not verify how the Libby app performs on an E Ink screen.

Before you buy, check that your own library offers Libby; Kobo points out that it may not be available at your local library.

Note-taking models: worth it or not?

A growing group of e-readers accept a stylus for handwriting and marking up books. Amazon's Kindle Scribe is pitched as a reader plus notebook with a Premium Pen and an AI notebook summary feature. Kobo's Libra Colour works with the Kobo Stylus 2, sold separately, with notebooks backed up to the Kobo Cloud. Boox's Go 7 and Go Color 7 (Gen II) support its InkSense pens, which Boox says have 4096 levels of pressure sensitivity and are also sold separately.

Questions to ask before paying extra for a pen:

  • Will you actually write on it? If you mostly read novels, a stylus is an accessory you may never charge.
  • Is the pen included? On the Kobo Libra Colour and Boox Go 7 series it is not, according to the makers' pages, so add its cost to the comparison.
  • Where do notes go? Check whether notes sync to a cloud you already use (Kobo lists Dropbox and Google Drive; Boox offers its own cloud) and whether you can export them.
  • Screen size matters more for writing. A 7-inch screen suits margin notes and quick lists; full-page note-taking and PDF annotation are easier on larger screens.

Other specs worth a glance

  • Storage: ebooks are small. Kobo assumes about 1.3 MB per ebook, which is why 16 GB or 32 GB holds thousands of books. Storage matters more for audiobooks, comics and PDFs. Boox adds a microSD card slot.
  • Page-turn buttons: physical buttons make one-handed reading easier. Kobo's Libra Colour and Boox's Go 7 series both have them.
  • Audiobooks: some readers play audiobooks over Bluetooth. Kobo notes Kobo Audiobooks are available only in select countries.
  • Repairability and updates: Kobo describes the Libra Colour as repairable, and Boox says it provides free firmware updates for more than 3 years after launch. Software support length affects how long store and library features keep working.
  • Charging: USB-C is now standard on the models we read about. Amazon lists wireless charging on its Paperwhite Signature Edition.

Buying checklist

  1. Pick your ecosystem first. Existing purchases, library use and country decide most of it.
  2. Confirm library support where you live. Kindle library loans via Libby are U.S.-only; Kobo's built-in OverDrive covers a listed set of countries.
  3. Choose a size. 6 inches for portability, 7 inches for comfort and buttons, 8 inches and up for PDFs and writing.
  4. Insist on about 300 ppi for text and accept that color content on Kaleido 3 is shown at 150 ppi.
  5. Get warm light if you read at night.
  6. Get IPX8 if you read near water, and read the maker's depth and time figures. "Water-repellent" is not waterproof.
  7. Only pay for a stylus if you will write. Check whether the pen is included.
  8. Check the return policy. Screen tone and color are personal; our guide on testing a product during the return window helps.

Buying one as a present? The ecosystem question matters even more, because the recipient's existing library and library card decide which brand is useful. Our guide on how to choose a gift that won't be returned covers how to find that out without spoiling the surprise.

Bottom line

Choose the bookstore and library system first, then the hardware. If you already buy Kindle books and live in the U.S., a Kindle keeps everything in one place and still lets you borrow through Libby. If you borrow heavily from a library, read DRM-free EPUBs, or live outside the U.S., a recent Kobo with built-in OverDrive is the more flexible choice in the countries Kobo lists. If you want Android apps from several stores plus handwriting, Boox is the open option, with the caveat that apps were not designed for E Ink and its Go 7 series is only water-repellent.

After that, the hardware rules are simple: about 300 ppi for text, warm light for night reading, IPX8 if you read near water, color only if you read illustrated content, and a stylus only if you will use it.

Limits of this article

  • This guide is research based. The Review NYU did not test any e-reader hands-on; specs and battery figures are maker claims.
  • There are no product images because we have no licensed photos of these devices.
  • Amazon's Kindle product and help pages were partly blocked to our tools, so Kindle-specific specs (such as ppi and exact water-rating depth) are not quoted; we relied on Amazon's own buying guide and the Send to Kindle page.
  • The IEC's own IP-ratings page returned an error, so IP code meanings come from a supplier's explainer (RS) rather than the standard itself.
  • Prices are not included because we could not verify retailer prices consistently on 21 November 2026; makers' list prices change often, especially around Black Friday.
  • We did not check how third-party apps, including Libby, behave on Android-based E Ink readers such as Boox.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

Can I borrow library books on a Kindle?

Yes, in the U.S. Libby's help page says most Libby books can be read on a Kindle e-reader, available in the U.S. only. You borrow in Libby, choose Read With Kindle, and finish on Amazon's website.

Which Kobo e-readers have OverDrive built in?

Kobo lists the Libra Colour, Clara Colour, Clara BW, Elipsa 2E, Clara 2E, Sage, Libra 2, Elipsa, Nia, Libra H2O, Forma, Aura ONE, Aura Edition 2, Aura H2O Edition 2 and Clara HD, in 13 countries including the U.S., Canada, the U.K., Australia and New Zealand.

What does IPX8 mean on an e-reader?

The X means no dust rating was given; the 8 means protection against immersion beyond the IPX7 test, with the exact depth and time set by the maker. Kobo, for example, states up to 60 minutes in up to 2 metres of water for the Libra Colour.

Can a Kindle read EPUB files?

Amazon's Send to Kindle service lists EPUB among its supported file types, along with PDF, DOC, DOCX and others, with a 200 MB maximum file size. You send the file through Amazon's service rather than copying it onto the device.

Is a color e-reader worth it?

Only if you read comics, illustrated books or want colored highlights. On current Kaleido 3 color screens, makers quote 300 ppi for black-and-white content but 150 ppi for color, and colors look muted compared with a tablet.

Do I need a stylus on an e-reader?

Only if you plan to handwrite notes or mark up books. On the Kobo Libra Colour and Boox Go 7 series the pen is sold separately, so include it in the price comparison.