Most returned gifts miss on fit, function or taste. This guide gives you a simple way to check all three before you buy, plus what to do when you cannot.
The Review NYU is not affiliated with New York University.
We do not currently earn a commission from any link on this page. If links ever become affiliate links, we will label them clearly.
Short answer. Gifts get returned when they miss on fit, function or taste, and retailers expect a lot of that: in the NRF and Happy Returns 2025 Retail Returns Landscape, retailers said they expect 17% of holiday sales to come back. The most reliable way to beat those odds is to buy something the person has asked for. In Gino and Flynn’s 2011 studies, recipients appreciated requested gifts more than surprises, while givers wrongly assumed it made no difference. If there is no list, score the idea on three things: use (a real problem it solves, used weekly), quality (one better version beats several cheap ones) and habits (it fits the phone, sizes, routines and taste they already have). When you cannot score it confidently, choose a consumable, an experience or a gift card, and always include a gift receipt.
This is a research-based guide, not a hands-on test. The Review NYU did not buy, give or return any gifts for this article. We read the National Retail Federation’s October 2025 returns press release (the latest NRF returns report we could find on 18 November 2026), a British Psychological Society summary of Francesca Gino and Francis Flynn’s 2011 paper “Give them what they want”, the listing for Cindy Chan and Cassie Mogilner’s paper on experiential versus material gifts, and November 2026 news coverage of retailer holiday return windows.
Where we only saw a search-result excerpt rather than the full page, we say so in the Limits section. The framework itself (use, quality, habits) is our synthesis of that research plus standard buying advice we apply across our other guides; it is a way of thinking, not a measured result.
Returns are a normal part of retail, not a rare failure. According to the NRF and Happy Returns, retailers estimated that 15.8% of their annual sales would be returned in 2025, worth about $849.9 billion, and that 19.3% of online sales would come back. For the holiday season specifically, retailers expected 17% of sales to be returned, a figure the NRF described as consistent with previous years.
The NRF data does not break down why gifts in particular are returned, so we will not invent a ranking. In practice, though, a returned gift usually fails in one of a few predictable ways:
Each of those failures maps onto one part of the framework below. Use covers the “no use” problem, quality covers the flimsy gift, and the recipient’s habits cover fit, duplicates and taste.
The single best-supported piece of advice is also the least romantic: give people what they say they want. In three studies summarised by the British Psychological Society, Gino and Flynn found that people receiving gifts appreciated items they had requested more than surprise gifts, and saw those requested gifts as more thoughtful and more personal. People giving gifts, by contrast, expected no difference.
One of the studies used real Amazon wish lists with 90 participants. Givers who picked from the list were rated as more thoughtful than givers told to pick a surprise item, even though the givers themselves did not predict this. The researchers’ practical advice, quoted in the summary, was that givers should pay attention to registries, wish lists and explicit requests.
If asking is not possible, the rest of this guide is about making a good guess.
A gift that gets used every week is hard to return because it quickly becomes part of someone’s routine. Before buying, try to finish this sentence: “They will use this to ___, about ___ times a week.” If you cannot fill in both blanks, the gift is probably decorative or speculative.
Our guide to testing a product during the return window has a checklist you can share with the recipient so they try the gift properly before deciding.
For the same budget, one well-made item usually beats a bundle of cheaper ones. A good pair of wool socks, a well-reviewed charger from a known brand or a sturdy water bottle will be kept; a novelty gift set is more likely to be regifted or returned.
Quality also means buying the current, supported version. For tech, an older model may stop getting software updates sooner, which matters more for a phone or tablet than for a speaker.
This is where most avoidable returns happen. A gift has to fit the person’s body, devices, home and taste, and you are guessing at all four.
Look at what they own and use, not what you think they should own. Neutral colours and the brands already in their home are the safer choice. If you notice they replace something regularly, a better version of that thing is a strong gift.
Use the table to pick a gift type based on how much you actually know. It is a rule of thumb from the research above, not a tested model.
| What you know | Best gift type | Why | Return risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| They gave you a list or named an item | The exact item on the list | Requested gifts were appreciated more in Gino and Flynn’s studies | Low |
| You know their routines and devices well | A better version of something they use daily | Strong on use, quality and habits | Low to medium |
| You know their interests, not their gear | Experience (tickets, class, meal) | Avoids size and compatibility; research links experiential gifts to closer relationships | Low, but check refund rules |
| You know their tastes in food or drink | Consumables (coffee, snacks, a favourite treat) | Gets used up, no clutter | Very low |
| You know the store, not the item | Gift card for that store or service | Recipient picks size, colour and model | None |
| You know very little | Cash or a widely accepted gift card | Recipients in one Gino and Flynn study preferred money | None |
| Clothes, shoes or tech with unknown fit | Avoid, or buy with a gift receipt | Most likely to miss on size or compatibility | High |
Cindy Chan and Cassie Mogilner’s paper, published in the Journal of Consumer Research, is titled “Experiential Gifts Foster Stronger Social Relationships than Material Gifts”, and ScienceDaily’s 2016 coverage summarised it as experiences being better gifts than material things. The authors’ finding was about relationship closeness, not return rates, so do not read it as proof that experiences are never wasted. Pick a date carefully, check the refund or rescheduling policy, and choose something you could attend together if that suits the relationship.
Food, drink, good coffee, bath products they already use and similar items get used up, which makes them hard to return and easy to enjoy. The risk is allergies and dietary rules, so check those first.
Gift cards feel impersonal to the giver, but the evidence suggests recipients mind less than givers think. In the final study described in the BPS summary, 107 students acting as recipients said they would appreciate money more than items they had asked for, while givers expected the opposite. A gift card makes the most sense when:
Pair it with a short note naming what you thought they might buy. That keeps the thought in the gift.
Even a well-chosen gift should be easy to exchange. Several large retailers have extended their return windows for holiday 2026. According to the New York Post (2 November 2026) and Fortune (8 November 2026), Amazon says most eligible items bought between 1 November and 31 December 2026 can be returned until 31 January 2027, with Apple-branded products on a shorter window. We read only search excerpts of those articles and did not check Amazon’s own policy page, so confirm the details at checkout.
Other retailers, including Target and Best Buy, also publish holiday windows, but the dates and exceptions in the coverage we saw differed by category, with phones and some electronics often on shorter deadlines. Check each retailer’s policy page for the exact cut-off before buying; Yahoo Shopping’s November 2026 roundup collects several of them.
Retailers expect this season: in the NRF survey, 37% of retailers said they planned to extend return windows to manage holiday returns. The same report found that 82% of consumers call free returns a major consideration when buying.
The gift least likely to be returned is the one the person asked for. When you cannot ask, check three things: that it solves a real problem they face often, that it is the better-made version, and that it fits the phone, sizes and taste they already have. If you cannot answer those confidently, an experience, something consumable or a gift card is a reasonable choice, and research suggests recipients like cash and requested items more than givers expect. Whatever you buy, check the holiday return deadline and include a gift receipt.
Before you buy on a big sale day, read our guide on how to tell if a sale is a real deal.
The NRF does not track gifts separately, but in its 2025 Retail Returns Landscape report retailers said they expect about 17% of holiday sales to be returned, consistent with previous years.
The research suggests not. In Gino and Flynn’s 2011 studies, recipients appreciated requested gifts more than surprises and saw them as more thoughtful. Asking for a short list and choosing one item keeps some surprise.
Givers tend to think so, but recipients in one Gino and Flynn study said they would appreciate money more than items they had asked for. A card for a store the person already uses, with a short note, is a reasonable choice.
Find out first, by asking a partner or family member if needed. Earbuds, smartwatches, chargers and trackers can depend on iPhone or Android compatibility, so check the product’s compatibility page before buying.
Yes. It lets the recipient exchange the gift without seeing the price, and it costs you nothing. Keep your own order confirmation too, in case the receipt is lost.
It depends on the retailer and the product. News coverage says Amazon allows most items bought from 1 November to 31 December 2026 to be returned until 31 January 2027, with shorter windows for some products, so check each retailer’s policy before buying.