Start with the hikes you actually do, then get the fit right; the rest of the features follow from those two decisions.
The Review NYU is not affiliated with New York University.
We do not currently earn a commission from any link on this page. If links ever become affiliate links, we will label them clearly.
Short answer. Choose hiking footwear by terrain, distance and pack weight, then prioritise fit over features. REI says boots should be snug everywhere but tight nowhere, with about a thumb's width of space in front of your longest toe. Stiffer, higher boots make most sense for heavy loads and rugged ground; the research on tall collars preventing sprains is mixed. Waterproof membranes keep out rain and puddles but breathe less and dry slowly. For day hikes on maintained trails with a light pack, a hiking shoe or trail runner is often enough.
This is a research-based guide, not a hands-on test. The Review NYU did not test any boots or shoes for this article. On 17 November 2026 we read two REI Co-op Expert Advice articles in full: How to Choose Hiking Boots and Hiking Shoes (updated 18 May 2026) and Hiking Boots vs. Hiking Shoes. To check the most argued-over claim, that taller boots protect your ankles, we also read search excerpts from a peer-reviewed study on high-top and low-top shoes hosted by the US National Library of Medicine, and a MUSC Health article summarising the same research.
REI sells the footwear it writes about, so we treat its advice as experienced retail guidance rather than independent evidence. Where a number appears below, it is linked to where it came from. Where the sources disagree or the evidence is thin, we say so.
REI sorts hiking footwear by three questions: how long or far you go, how rough the terrain is, and how much you carry. Here is how the common types line up, in rough order from lightest to heaviest.
Lighter and more flexible than hiking shoes, built for faster movement and quick changes of direction. REI says they suit light to moderate terrain, and that fastpackers and thru-hikers often prefer them to heavier boots. The trade-off is lifespan: REI says they typically last about 500 miles before needing replacement.
Low-cut shoes with tougher uppers and moderately flexible midsoles. REI describes them as a balance between running shoes and boots, and says low-cut, flexible models can replace boots entirely for some day hikers. They usually need no break-in.
REI describes these as intended for day hikes or short backpacking trips with light loads. They flex easily and need little break-in, but lack the support and durability of full backpacking boots. Best for light or moderate terrain.
Built for heavier loads on multiday trips. Most are high-cut, with stiffer midsoles than lighter footwear, and REI rates them for moderate to rugged terrain, on or off trail. They are heavier, less breathable and need breaking in.
Considerably stiffer and often taller, for snowy peaks and rough ground. REI notes they use three-quarter or full-length shanks, and that crampon compatibility matters: a crampon strapped to a flexible-soled boot will not fit as securely as on a rigid one. Most hikers do not need these.
This table condenses the guidance in REI's boot guide and boots vs shoes article. The pack volumes and mileage figures are REI's; treat them as rules of thumb, not limits.
| Type | Best for (per REI) | Typical load | Break-in | Main trade-off |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Trail-running shoe | Faster hikes, light to moderate terrain | Light day pack | None | Less underfoot protection; about 500 miles of life |
| Hiking shoe | Day hikes, groomed or moderate trails | Light day pack | None | Less ankle coverage; not built for heavy packs |
| Day hiking boot (mid/high) | Short trails to several hours, light to moderate terrain | Packs under 35 liters | Some | Heavier and less breathable than shoes |
| Backpacking boot | Multiday trips, moderate to rugged terrain | Up to about 70 to 75 liters | Yes | Heavy; too stiff for many day hikes |
| Mountaineering boot | Snow, ice, big elevation gain | 75 to 100 liters | Yes | Expensive, heavy, specialised |
REI's summary of good fit is that hiking footwear should be snug everywhere but tight nowhere, with room to wiggle your toes. A well-chosen boot type that fits badly will still give you blisters. The practical checks:
Check the return policy before buying; our guide on testing a product during the return window covers how to do that without voiding it.
REI says flexible hiking shoes and trail runners do not need a break-in period, but most sturdier hiking, backpacking and mountaineering boots do. Wear them on walks and short hikes before a long trip. Full-grain and nubuck leather in particular need ample break-in time, according to the same guide.
Support means two things: how high the boot comes up your ankle, and how stiff the sole is.
The midsole largely determines stiffness, and REI argues that stiffer footwear can mean more comfort and stability on long, rocky hikes. Some boots add a 3 to 5 millimeter thick shank between midsole and outsole for load-bearing stiffness; some trail shoes use a rock plate instead, which resists twisting and stops sharp rocks from bruising your feet.
The heavier your pack, the more sole stiffness helps. That is the main case REI makes for backpacking boots: their higher cuts and stiffer midsoles add stability when you carry a heavy load.
This is where the evidence is weaker than the marketing. REI says mid- and high-cut boots offer ankle support when worn correctly, but also notes that for some people a tall collar feels restrictive, and that the stiffness and height of a boot can reduce movement and responsiveness.
The research we found is mixed and mostly not about hiking. A lab study of landings on a tilted surface reported no significant difference in maximum ankle inversion between high-top and low-top shoes, and its literature review notes that epidemiological studies, largely in basketball, found no clear difference in sprain rates between high-tops and low-tops, even though some lab studies found that high-tops reduced inversion. MUSC Health reached a similar summary. Our reading: a high collar may help some people, especially with a heavy pack or a history of sprains, but it is not a guarantee. Fit, sole stiffness and watching your footing matter at least as much.
Boots sold as waterproof use a waterproof/breathable membrane, such as GORE-TEX or eVent, inside the upper. REI notes the downside plainly: a membrane breathes less than the open mesh on many non-waterproof shoes, which can make your feet sweat on summer days.
The bigger issue is drying. According to REI, hiking boots resist water but take much longer to dry once they do get wet, while breathable hiking shoes dry quickly.
A practical way to decide:
The outsole is the rubber that meets the ground. REI explains the basic trade-off: harder rubber lasts longer but can feel slick off trail, while softer rubber grips and cushions better but wears faster. A pronounced heel brake helps on steep descents.
Lugs, the bumps on the sole, should match your terrain. REI's guidance:
| Terrain or conditions | Lug pattern REI recommends |
|---|---|
| Dry, groomed, mostly flat trail | Moderately deep, not widely spaced |
| Mud, elevation gain | Deep and widely spaced, to shed mud |
| Rocky, uneven ground | Deep and multidirectional |
| Snow or ice | Deep and aggressive |
| Wet, smooth rock | Shallower and tightly spaced, for more contact area |
Weight is the other big lever. REI says a light hiking shoe can weigh as little as 1 pound and a sturdy boot more than 3 pounds, and repeats the backpacker saying that a pound on your feet equals five on your back. Only carry boot weight when the support or protection is worth it.
For many hikers, a hiking shoe or trail runner is all they need. REI says lighter shoes may be the better option if you carry a light pack, stay close to home, or walk groomed or paved trails, and that they are easier to break in and often better for balance.
Trail shoes are usually enough when most of these are true:
Boots earn their weight when you carry a heavy multiday load, hike rugged or off-trail terrain, travel in cold, wet or snowy conditions, or need crampons.
If you already run on trails, our running shoe guide covers cushioning and drop in more detail.
REI suggests pulling out the insole and standing on it: there should be about a thumb's width between your longest toe and the end. On a downhill slope your toes should not hit the front of the boot.
Not reliably. Some lab studies found high-tops reduce ankle inversion, but other studies and injury data, mostly from basketball, found no clear difference in sprain rates. A stiff sole, good fit and careful footing matter as well.
No. Membranes keep out rain and puddles but breathe less, so feet can sweat in warm weather, and wet boots dry slowly. Non-waterproof shoes are often better on hot, dry trails or routes with deep crossings.
Yes, for many day hikes on maintained trails with a light pack. REI notes that fastpackers and thru-hikers often prefer them, though they offer less underfoot protection and typically last about 500 miles.
Flexible hiking shoes and trail runners generally do not need it. Sturdier boots, especially leather ones, should be worn on walks and short hikes before a long trip.
Late in the day, when your feet have swollen to their largest, and while wearing the socks and any orthotics you plan to hike in.